Cape May, NJ, a charming coastal town nestled by the stunning Cape May Harbor and lively Beach Avenue, offers an abundance of dining experiences, from casual beachside eateries to elegant fine dining. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, discovering the best restaurants in Cape May is a culinary adventure. Among these gems is the idyllic Beach Plum Farm in West Cape May, a 62-acre working farm that offers a unique farm-to-table experience, where fresh ingredients are sourced directly from the farm. As we explore the best restaurants in Cape May, NJ, we’ll uncover a diverse array of dining options, from the renowned Ebbitt Room to the newly expanded Phinney’s Pub.
Cape May Beach Restaurants: A Culinary Adventure
Cape May is home to a vibrant food scene, known for its commitment to fresh, locally sourced ingredients and innovative culinary techniques. Whether you’re searching for Cape May beach restaurants with breathtaking ocean views or hidden gems tucked away in quieter corners, this guide will help you navigate the best dining spots in this picturesque town.
Pier House at La Mer Beachfront Resort
Nestled within La Mer Beachfront Resort, the Pier House Restaurant and Terrace offers an unforgettable dining experience that blends coastal charm with modern elegance. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor exploring the beauty of Cape May, the Pier House promises a culinary journey that delights the senses. The menu is a celebration of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, crafted into innovative dishes by the restaurant’s talented chefs. From ocean-fresh seafood to perfectly grilled steaks, each dish is prepared with care and creativity, ensuring every bite is a moment to savor. Paired with carefully curated selection of wines and handcrafted co*cktails, your dining experience is elevated to new heights.
Address: 1317 Beach Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: On-site
Phone: (609) 884-9000
Taco Caballito Tequileria
For those seeking a vibrant atmosphere with a modern Mexican twist, Taco Caballito Tequileria on Beach Avenue is the place to be. This Cape May restaurant offers a unique blend of artisanal tequila and eclectic Mexican cuisine. With over 70 tequilas from small, artisan distilleries and a menu full of creative dishes, it’s a must-visit for those who love bold flavors and a lively ambiance.
Address: 429 Beach Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 0.4 miles (approximately 8-minute walk)
Phone: (609) 884-4800
Washington Inn & Wine Bar
A historic gem, the Washington Inn has been a staple in Cape May since 1846. Known for its warm hospitality and exceptional New American cuisine, this restaurant offers a dining experience steeped in history and charm. Whether you’re enjoying a romantic dinner or a special celebration, the Washington Inn is one of the best restaurants in Cape May, offering a refined yet welcoming atmosphere.
Address: 801 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.2 miles (approximately 5-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 884-5697
Grana BYOB
Grana BYOB is a modern American restaurant that takes a minimalist approach to fine dining. Located on South Broadway, this Cape May gem is dedicated to using local, seasonal ingredients to create dishes that highlight the best of the season. With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, Grana BYOB offers something for everyone. Bring your favorite bottle of wine and enjoy an intimate dining experience that focuses on quality and flavor.
Address: 413 South Broadway, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.7 miles (approximately 6-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 849-9255
Mayer’s Tavern
Known as a hidden gem for fresh local seafood, Mayer’s Tavern has been a beloved part of the Cape May community since the 1940s. After recent renovations, this classic tavern has been reinvigorated while maintaining its historic charm. With excellent co*cktails, live music, and a welcoming atmosphere, Mayer’s Tavern is a must-visit for those looking to experience the best of Cape May’s local flavor.
Address: 894 3rd Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.3 miles (approximately 4-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 435-5078
Sapore Italiano
In West Cape May, Sapore Italiano offers a cozy spot where you can indulge in authentic Italian cuisine. The warm hospitality and delicious scents of Italian cooking create the perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. The menu features classic dishes made with the freshest ingredients, making it one of the top Italian restaurants in Cape May.
Address: 416 South Broadway, West Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.8 miles (approximately 6-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 600-1422
Exit Zero Filling Station
A local legend in its own right, Exit Zero Filling Station offers a unique dining experience with a menu that blends Indian and Thai curries with American comfort food. Located on Sunset Boulevard, this Cape May restaurant is also known for its excellent burgers and creative co*cktails. Outdoor dining is dog-friendly, making it a great spot for a casual meal with friends or family.
Address: 110 Sunset Boulevard, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.9 miles (approximately 7-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 770-8479
Cricket Club
Once known as The Merion Inn, the Cricket Club is a newly transformed Cape May restaurant that pays homage to its historic roots. The menu offers generous portions of classic American dishes with a modern twist. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the Merion or a first-time visitor, the Cricket Club is sure to impress with its thoughtful renovations and delicious cuisine.
Address: 106 Decatur Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.3 miles (approximately 5-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 888-6095
The Mad Batter
A staple of Cape May’s dining scene, The Mad Batter has been serving up delicious meals since 1976. Located in the historic Carroll Villa Hotel, this restaurant offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner year-round. Whether you’re dining on the front porch, in the skylit dining room, or in the garden terrace, The Mad Batter is a must-visit for anyone exploring Cape May’s culinary delights.
Address: 19 Jackson Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.3 miles (approximately 5-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 884-5970
The Lobster House
Overlooking Cape May Harbor, The Lobster House is one of the most iconic Cape May beach restaurants. With five dining rooms and a full bar, this waterfront restaurant offers a nautical atmosphere and a menu that celebrates the best of the Jersey Shore’s seafood. The Schooner American, a 130-foot authentic Grand Banks sailing vessel, serves as an outdoor co*cktail lounge, providing a unique dining experience with stunning views of the harbor.
Address: 906 Schellengers Landing Road, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.4 miles (approximately 5-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 884-8296
Lucky Bones Back Water Grille
A casual, friendly spot, Lucky Bones Back Water Grille offers a menu full of international flavors and comfort foods. Whether you’re in the mood for steamed clams, fried oysters, or a classic cheeseburger, Lucky Bones has something for everyone. The warm atmosphere and made-from-scratch dishes make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Address: 1200 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204
Distance from La Mer Beachfront Resort: 1.5 miles (approximately 5-minute drive)
Phone: (609) 884-2663
Cape May, NJ, is a culinary paradise with a wide variety of dining options to suit every taste. From waterfront restaurants with breathtaking views to cozy bistros offering authentic Italian cuisine, the best restaurants in Cape May offer a truly unforgettable dining experience. Embark on a culinary adventure and explore the hidden gems that make this charming coastal town a food lover’s dream. Whether you’re savoring fresh seafood at one of the Cape May beach restaurants or enjoying a farm-to-table meal at a local gem, your taste buds are in for an unforgettable experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes these Cape May restaurants unique?
These restaurants are celebrated for their use of fresh, local seafood from the Jersey Shore and their commitment to delivering exceptional dining experiences. The culinary staff is dedicated to highlighting the best of Cape May’s local ingredients, ensuring that each meal is both memorable and delicious.
How do I choose which Cape May restaurant to visit first?
Consider your preferred dining atmosphere and cuisine. Whether you’re seeking fine dining with an ocean view, a casual spot with local flavor, or a cozy Italian bistro, Cape May offers a diverse array of restaurants to explore. Start with what appeals most to your taste and enjoy the culinary delights this coastal town has to offer.
